Skip to content
Public archive · works of fiction
Superseded

Corrections and withdrawals

Fiction almost never does this, because fiction has no cost of being wrong. The printed volumes do. This page carries the withdrawals as they stand in the compilations, and will carry the next ones.

HHDRVThis compilation

The optical reconstruction of the mirror phenomenon

HHDRV Ch. 19 · Compiler's note

Earlier revisions attributed the missing reflection to an anti-reflective property of the dermal metabolic oil, and to narrow-band destructive interference between that oil and the silver backing in the near-ultraviolet.

  1. 01

    An anti-reflective layer on the skin governs how much light the skin returns; it does not govern whether the mirror forms an image. Baseline human skin is already an overwhelmingly diffuse reflector, and a mirror renders it perfectly well. The earlier account confused the optics of the subject with the optics of the reflector.

  2. 02

    Interference in the near-ultraviolet cannot degrade an image assembled by the human eye from visible wavelengths, and the soda-lime glass of every mirror under discussion is in any case substantially opaque below approximately 350 nanometres.

  3. 03

    Thin-film interference of the kind invoked requires an optically uniform layer of controlled thickness and a coherent source, and no sebaceous secretion spread across the topography of a human face satisfies either requirement.

Replacement
Two stacked conditions. Cumulative silver-sulphide foxing on unsealed silver-backed mirrors — conservation literature, not a claim of the organism — and a refractive gradient in the cold boundary layer, light twice at thirty to sixty centimetres. Aluminium vapour-deposition from the 1930s forms no sulphide and self-passivates. The present account is offered at a lower confidence grade than the galvanic mechanism that precedes it in the same chapter. Falsification is Path Four-A. The compiler withdraws the earlier mechanism without reservation.
HHDRV Ch. 19 · Compiler's note

Anyone who finds an error later is joining a process already running. Write the desk. The next line on this page will be a filing, not a defence.